Get The Listing, Keep The Listing › Guides › Is it the price, or is it you? Answering the day-60 question
Keeping the listing

Is it the price, or is it you? Answering the day-60 question

Somewhere around the second month, the seller's question changes. They stop asking what the market is doing and start wondering whether they picked the right agent. Answer that one, out loud, before they ask it somewhere else.

They're not asking about the price.

"Do you think it's the price, or is it something else?" sounds like a pricing question. It isn't. It's the seller asking whether anyone is still working on their house, and whether the person they hired is the reason it hasn't sold. Every seller gets there eventually. A quiet listing gives them time to think, and this is what they think about.

The worst thing you can do is defend yourself. The second worst is to dodge into market talk. Both tell the seller you heard the real question and didn't want to answer it. So answer it. Calmly, with the facts in front of you, and without flinching.

Say the question before they do.

You know roughly when this moment comes. So get there first. Around the sixth or seventh week, open your update or your call with it. "At this point in a listing, most sellers start wondering whether it's the price or the agent. That's a fair question, and I'd rather we look at it together than have you wonder about it alone."

That one sentence changes who's holding the question. When you raise it, it's a review. When they raise it, it's an accusation. Same words, completely different room. And a seller who hears their agent name the hard question stops assuming the agent is hiding from it.

Let's put both answers on the table.

Split the listing into two columns. What you controlled, and what the market controlled. Your column: how the house was photographed and where it was marketed. How many showings were booked. How fast you followed up for feedback. The open houses you held and the agents you called back. Show the work, item by item, with dates. Not as a defense. As a record.

The market's column: what listed nearby since you went live, what went under contract, what closed and at what price, and how your seller's house sits against all of it. This is the column that answers the price question, and it answers it without you having to say a word about your own effort.

Walk through both. Then ask: "Looking at these together, what do you see?" Most sellers see it before you have to say it.

If part of it is you, say so.

Sometimes it is. The photos were rushed. The description buried the best room. You took a week to get feedback from the first showings. If something in your column could have been better, name it and fix it in the same breath. "The listing photos aren't doing the backyard justice. I've booked a reshoot for Thursday."

A seller forgives a fix. What they don't forgive is finding out later that you knew and said nothing. Owning the small thing is what makes them believe you about the big thing, which is almost always the price.

Then decide the next move together.

Don't leave the meeting with a feeling. Leave it with a decision. Price, condition, or hold with a date. "Here's what the market is telling us. Here are the three moves available. Which one do you want to make, and when do we check it?" Write it down and put it in the next update.

The seller who had this conversation on time doesn't go shopping for another agent at day 75. They don't need to. The question that sends sellers shopping was asked and answered, with the numbers doing the talking. That's the job in one meeting, and you ran it!

Common questions

What if the seller has already talked to another agent?

Assume they have, and don't take it personally. Ask what that agent said and walk through it against the numbers you have. If the other agent promised a higher price with no comps to back it, let the comps answer. If they named something you missed, fix it.

What if I'm sure it really is just the price?

Show the work column anyway. A seller can't hear "it's the price" from an agent they suspect of coasting. Once they can see you did the job, the price conversation is a market conversation instead of a blame conversation.

Should I offer to let them out of the listing?

Don't lead with it. Lead with the review and the next move. If they still want out after seeing the full picture, that's a conversation about your agreement. Read what yours says together before anyone promises anything.

Send this every week without building it by hand.

Get The Listing, Keep The Listing writes the weekly seller report in your name: their showings against the market, the homes competing with theirs, and what buyer agents said. You read it and send it from your own inbox.